Single Battle: David Cook v. David Archuleta

Now, I'm sure some will argue this single battle isn't fair because David Cook's first single was the coronation single, but it seems like the top 3 hit "Time of My Life" is getting a second wind.

In that case, what single is truly better?

Here's David C's:



And here's David A's:



After hearing both, which one do you like the most?